CASE OF DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF CASTE AND INJUSTICE .
APPEAL AND RECONSIDER YOUR DECESION¬¬¬

Baldev Raj Mahi, S/o Sh.Ram Asra,
Nawanshahar (Pb)
Ex-Manager,
Dated: 18-03-2012
Baba Deep Singh Nagar,
Saloh Road,
Backside K.C.Palace, Nawanshahr (Punjab)
Distt.Sahid Bhagat Singh Nagar


Sh G . S DUBEY
THE GENERAL MANAGER
(APPELLATE AUTHORITY )
PERSONAL ADMINSTRATION DIVISION.
Punjab National Bank,
Head Office, 7, Bhikaiji Cama Place,
New Delhi-110066

Regarding : Ill-legal Change Sheet Dated 05/10/2009 saved upon Sh. B.R.Mahi – Appeal and Reconsider your decision . A case of discrimination on the basis of schedule caste
Sir,
Vide your order dated 10/12/2011 my appeal against major penalty of compulsory retirement imposed upon me by the Disciplinary Authority of General Category i.e DGM,
Circle office, Hoshiarpur has been rejected by yourgoodself . I want to submit following facts for your kind perusal and reconsideration in the above matter please .
1) I am shocked to see this decision without any base and going into merits of the case . i was hoping that you will decide the case after going through the facts of the case . You did not care to go into the details of the case and my appeal dated 14/9/11 fully. I asked for the documents from the Bank to defend myself but these documents were not supplied to me before the Enquiry.
2) Appeal means that you should have gone through the whole case and give your independent decision, but the decision taken by you is fully based on the facts presented by lower authority against whose decision appeal has been made, who all were belonging from general category and who all discriminated against me on the basis caste as I belong to scheduled caste.
3) Lower authority presented the whole case in a biased manner and presented the case in a wrong manner. The wrong facts presented by lower authority have become the basis of your wrong & illegal decision whereas you should have studied the whole case in an impartial manner to give justice.
4) Most of the charges which were proved against me while I was away to a foreign country. My leave was duly sanctioned by competent authority which is on record. This fact has been concealed by lower authorities from your good self. Copy of Passport is enclosed herewith for your kind perusal which clearly shows that during this period I was away from India.
5) On 17/5/2005 I was posted in BO Rahon and charges relating to this period have been proved against me, how this is possible to prove charges against me and not against the manager working in BO, Usmanpur my predecessor.
6) All loan A/cs has been fully secured with collateral security and there is no apprehension of loss to the Bank. These facts has been wrongly communicated to yourgoodself by the officers who belongs to general category who all discriminated me on the basis of caste as I belong to scheduled caste.

Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,

(B.R.Mahi)
(BALDEV RAJ MAHI)
PF NO . 52135
MANAGER PNB, LDM OFFICE HOSHIARPUR ( PUNJAB)
Phone no : 0********75
Email id : baldevmahi@yahoo.com